Skip to content
PawCostly

Pet Insurance Claim Checklist: Before You File and If It Is Denied

Check who pays the vet, waiting periods, preexisting conditions and limits before you file; send an itemized invoice and records; expect to cover your share; and know where to complain.

Photograph of printed forms, clipped receipts and a pen on a desk with a cat asleep in the sun
On this page

Pet insurance claim checklist

Check these before you file and again if a claim is denied. Your policy document has the final word on your own terms.

0 of 12 done

Before you file

Making the claim

If the claim is denied

  • Both numbers are from those departments' pages. Your own state's department handles your policy.

    Source: Washington Office of the Insurance Commissioner, Pet insurance

Sources (4)

What this checklist is based on

Neither state brochure used here gives step-by-step claim instructions, so this list is built from what regulators say about how policies work, turned into things to check. Washington's insurance commissioner explains who pays the vet and how limits apply. California's department of insurance explains deductibles, coinsurance, waiting periods and exclusions. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners' consumer article lists what to ask, and its model act defines waiting periods and preexisting conditions.

Items with no source note, such as asking for an itemized invoice and keeping copies, are practical suggestions from this site. Your own policy document is what counts, and the checklist cannot tell you what it covers.

Worked example: a claim after a waiting period

Say your pet needed treatment three weeks after you bought a policy. The first question is the waiting period: California's department says that costs for treatment before the end of the waiting period are not covered. Check the policy for the length of any waiting period and the date coverage began, and compare it with the date of treatment. If the date falls inside the period, the checklist's answer is to expect the claim to fail and to ask the insurer in writing to confirm the reason.

If the date is outside, move on to preexisting conditions. The NAIC model act defines a preexisting condition as one that met certain tests before the policy started or during a waiting period, including a vet giving medical advice or earlier treatment. Then check the exclusions for hereditary and congenital conditions, and the annual and lifetime limits. Only then send the itemized invoice and the vet's records with the insurer's form.

What you will still pay

Several items in the second section are about money you should expect to pay yourself. California says the vet will expect you to pay the deductible or coinsurance amount, and that when a policy pays on a schedule or on usual and customary charges, the vet will expect the unpaid balance from you. Washington notes that some companies pay the vet and others reimburse you after you have paid the full bill. For an unplanned bill, that can mean paying first and waiting.

If a claim is denied

Ask the insurer to explain the denial in writing and to point to the clause. If it still looks wrong, your state insurance department takes complaints. Washington's consumer advocacy line is 800-562-6900, and California's consumer assistance hotline is 1-800-927-4357; use the department for the state your policy is issued in.

Related pages: the terms explainer defines each word used above, is it worth it covers the decision, and pet insurance cost shows published averages. Your ticks live in this browser, so copy or print the list to take it with you.

Sources

  1. Washington Office of the Insurance Commissioner, Pet insurance insurance.wa.gov
  2. California Department of Insurance, Pet Insurance (June 2023) insurance.ca.gov
  3. NAIC, Consumer insight: pet insurance (2018) content.naic.org
  4. NAIC, Pet Insurance Model Act (combined text) content.naic.org